A Personal Touch: Exploration of Genre
A critical component
in the education of a modern scholar involves the use of skepticism and
rhetorical analysis in order to understand the implications of any situation in
which they find themselves. While this skill is invaluable to possess, it can
be further enhanced with some simple communication with others involved in a
similar position. By listening to the viewpoint of others we can in turn create
a better understanding of something for ourselves, making human interaction
quite critical to a great deal of things. The context in which I would like to
explore this issue is within the genre of personal reviews. This genre applies
to a variety of things, such as restaurants, hotels, products, and media, and
can have a profound effect on our spending habits if used correctly.
“’Microwave for One’
is not just a cookbook. It is a lifestyle. Sonia Allison gave me the confidence
needed to rebuild my life.” – Drew. While searching for an easy recipe book to
give my ‘culinarily-challenged’ sister for Christmas, I sifted through dozens
of seemingly identical books with nothing to distinguish them. After countless
minutes of tedious searching, I came across this review and knew this had to be
the book for her! In an age of online shopping comes a severe limitation on
one’s ability as a consumer to find a suitable product without seeing it in the
flesh, it is time to adapt and learn to heed the good word of others and trust
in the opinion of our fellow shoppers. The genre of ‘reviews’ includes a broad
expanse of unique voices and opinions, but follows a basic guideline with
conventions and standards that enable efficient communication between
consumers.
Whether it comes in
the form of an inspiring product review, a cold-blooded scolding of a
restaurant’s service, or a pleasant recounting of a good hotel stay, all
individual reviews provide us with valuable information to assist in our
decision making process. This is due to the exigence of our fellow consumer
trying to find the best value for their money and passing their knowledge onto
others. The audience for this genre involves others searching to find a similar
product or service, which elicits a sense of camaraderie and fellowship as one
attempts to persuade someone else for or against the good in question. Due to
the nature of the relationship between this rhetor and his audience, reviews
conventionally have a casual yet helpful tone, taking the form of a piece of friendly
advice (or a dire warning of trouble). The laid back atmosphere created by this
genre fulfills the purpose of attempting to persuade the reader and usually
leads to a sense of trust between the writer and his audience. In addition,
reviews tend to be quite concise and direct, devoid of filler or distraction
which would detract from the efficiency of communication. Due to these critical
factors, the genre of personal review can be a valuable tool for anyone looking
to put their trust into others and make efficient and informed decisions in the
process of consumerism.
Tyler,
ReplyDeleteI hope you don’t mind if I just leave you a quick review on your PB! I feel that writing on reviews was a good idea. It was not a genre that popped in my head, but you’re very accurate in saying that they assist with decision making. I know I frequently use them (especially the bad reviews) to determine if I wish to make an online purchase or not. Your story about shopping for your sister was very relatable and provided credibility to your analysis of this genre. Keep up the good work, and stuff!
- Bronwyn Sivak
I agree with you when you said human interaction is critical to our everyday life. I think the things we do and how we do them are greatly influenced by what others have to say. Especially when we’re going to purchase something, we as consumers want the item we’re buying to be of best quality. Personally, I like to read reviews before I purchase something; this also includes movies and shows that I choose to watch. You also brought up a good point in considering the credibility of the reviewers. For all we know they could be lying, which brings the importance of trust and honesty in these reviews.
ReplyDeleteEttner,
ReplyDeleteReviews are a nice pick here for a genre analysis—they provide both similarities and differences that can help you (a student who is studying genre) see how genres have recurring patterns but also deviations from the norm.
So you’re absolutely right that reviews “do things” in the world—people seek them out to find out what’s good and what’s ehhhhh not so good. And you’re also right that they reflect people’s opinions—hopefully, though not always, backed by actual examples and reasons for those beliefs.
But what else are the conventions? What ingredients, features, or patterns do they have? Some that I can think of are quantitative aspect like # of stars; a paragraph or two, detailing the user’s experience with the product; some background info on the product itself; pictures of the product; and maybe even a user profile for social media-related sites like Yelp. This is what I mean when I ask, “So what are the conventions of this genre?”
In the future, I suggest finding actual real-life examples of whatever you’re examining—in this case, product review—so you can bring in some direct textual evidence to support your claims, and find some claims to make too. Also, on a rhetorical level, some visuals could help bring your blog to life.
Z